Consumer Reports has released reliability data comparing Kia and Toyota models across different vehicle segments.

Compact Crossovers

Toyota RAV4

Reliability Index: 66/100

One of the most dependable compact SUVs out there, the RAV4 stands out for its consistent performance and solid build quality.

Kia Sportage

Reliability Index: 60/100

With its sporty styling and appealing price tag, the Sportage is an attractive option, though its reliability trails the RAV4 by a narrow margin.

Both are solid choices, but the RAV4’s slight edge in reliability gives it the nod.

Midsize Sedans

Toyota Camry

Reliability Index: 83/100

The Camry remains the undisputed reliability champ among midsize sedans, pairing comfort, practicality, and long-term durability.

Kia K5

Reliability Index: 53/100

The K5 is a modern sedan with eye-catching design and an accessible price, but its quality still trails significantly behind its rival.

Thanks to its legendary reliability and broad popularity, the Camry easily holds onto its crown in this class.

Electric Vehicles

Toyota bZ4X

Reliability Index: 47/100

Toyota’s initial foray into the EV market hasn’t gone as smoothly, with the bZ4X posting modest reliability scores.

Kia EV6

Reliability Index: 48/100

The EV6, on the other hand, has drawn praise for its design and driving dynamics, though its reliability still falls short of expectations.

Neither brand has cracked the reliability code for electric vehicles yet, but the EV6’s overall package gives it a razor-thin lead over its rival.

Midsize SUVs

Toyota Grand Highlander

Reliability Index: 42/100

The refreshed Grand Highlander impresses with its roomy cabin and robust engine, but a low reliability rating mars the package.

Kia Telluride

Reliability Index: 54/100

The Telluride counters with comfort, sharp styling, and a well-thought-out interior, which gives it the upper hand here. Its reliability score may be modest, but it still outpoints the Toyota in this matchup.

Compact Cars

Toyota Corolla

Reliability Index: 72/100

A perennial favorite, the Corolla delivers a blend of proven reliability and affordability that’s hard to beat.

Kia Forte (replaced by the K4 model)

Reliability Index: 67/100

The outgoing Forte has been replaced by the K4, which shows real potential to challenge the Corolla. Though the Toyota still leads, the new Kia could meaningfully strengthen the brand’s standing in this segment going forward.

Summary

Overall, Toyota’s advantage largely rests on the exceptionally dependable Camry, which anchors its high scores. In most other segments, Kia holds its own, often delivering similar attributes at a more attractive price point. It’s also worth highlighting the steady reliability gains made by recent Kia models, which are slowly closing the gap with the Japanese brand.